Modified bitumen and single-ply are the two most common roofing membranes used in flat roofing systems. Single-ply membranes are cost-effective, lightweight, and easy to install. In contrast, modified bitumen membranes offer enhanced durability and are suitable for roofs that receive higher foot traffic, but they are more expensive and take longer to install.
What two types of roofing membranes are typically used in flat roofing systems?
While many different roofing solutions are available, they’re usually divided into single-ply membranes and modified bitumen membranes. Modified bitumen membranes are a hybrid material comprising multiple layers of asphalt, fibreglass, and polyester. In contrast, single-ply roof membranes are made from a single layer of synthetic materials.
What are single-ply membranes?
Single-ply membranes are a roofing solution that provides protection and waterproofing. They are factory-manufactured synthetic sheet materials made from various materials, including ethylene propylene diene monomer (EPDM – a naturally flexible material), polyvinyl chloride (PVC – versatile, lightweight and durable), thermoplastic polyolefin (TPO – high impact resistance, low density and good chemical resistance), and thermoplastic polyolefin elastomer (TPE – highly resistant to UV and doesn’t absorb moisture).
Single-ply membranes are lightweight, easy to install, and ensure long-lasting building protection, making them popular for commercial and residential roofing applications.
What are the advantages and disadvantages of single-ply membranes?
The advantages of single-ply membranes
- More affordable than pricier modified bitumen membranes.
- Quick and easy to install.
- The lightweight nature requires less structural support during installation and is an ideal choice for new buildings or retrofitting existing roofs.
- Single-ply roof membranes are heat-reflective (TPO only) and reduce solar heat absorption.
- Resistant to punctures, tears, chemical spills, oil, grease, and sunlight.
- Long-lasting waterproofing.
- Environmental benefits include reduced energy consumption, water management, and low maintenance.
The disadvantages of single-ply membranes
- Susceptible to wind uplift.
- Only one layer of protection is less durable than modified bitumen membranes (be mindful of trees that overhang the roof) and less suitable for heavy foot traffic.
What are bitumen membranes?
Bitumen membranes are roofing materials made from asphalt and reinforced with various materials, such as fibreglass and polyester. They are waterproof and durable and can be used on multiple types of roofs.
Modified bitumen membranes are combined with styrene-butadiene-styrene (SBS), a synthetic rubber that improves the membrane’s flexibility, strength, and durability. They are more expensive than traditional bitumen membranes.
What are the advantages and disadvantages of bitumen membranes?
The advantages of bitumen membranes
- Stronger and more durable than single-ply.
- Quick and easy to repair.
- If one layer fails, multiple layers protect the roof from water damage.
The disadvantages of bitumen membranes
- More expensive than single-ply membranes.
- It takes longer to install and requires highly trained installers.
- Torch-on applications need extra care to reduce the risk of a roof fire.
- Absorbs the sun’s UV rays, hurting the roof’s environmental footprint and your home’s energy efficiency.
What are the differences between single-ply and modified bitumen membranes?
Here is a summary of the key differences:
- Cost: Modified bitumen membranes have multiple layers, which increases material costs and makes them more costly than single-ply membranes.
- Material: Single-ply membranes are made from various polymers, including PVC, TPO, and EPDM. Modified bitumen membranes are made from asphalt modified with polymers or rubbers. They are typically reinforced with fibreglass or polyester, available in rolls, and installed using heat (torch-applied, hot-mopped) or cold adhesives.
- Installation: Single-ply membranes are typically easier and quicker to install than modified bitumen, which often involves mechanical attachment, ballasting, or chemical adhesion. Modified bitumen membranes require more labour-intensive techniques, such as torch-down application, cold-applied adhesives, or hot-mopped asphalt.
- Performance: Single-ply membranes resist UV radiation, ozone exposure, and chemical pollutants. They are flexible and provide long-lasting waterproofing. Modified bitumen membranes have flexible and elongation properties, making them suitable for areas with temperature fluctuations and building movement.
What are the future trends and innovations in roofing technology?
As the roofing industry evolves, new trends and innovations are emerging to enhance single-ply and modified bitumen membranes’ performance, sustainability, and efficiency.
Here are some key trends shaping roofing technology’s future:
Advanced materials: Researchers and manufacturers constantly develop new materials with improved durability, flexibility, and environmental sustainability. For single-ply membranes, advancements in polymer chemistry are leading to materials with enhanced UV resistance, weatherability, and recyclability. Similarly, modified bitumen membranes benefit from innovations in asphalt modifiers and reinforcement materials.
Green roofing solutions: The rising popularity of green roofs has spurred innovations in roofing technology aimed at supporting vegetative roofing systems. Green roofs have numerous environmental benefits. They provide building insulation, reduce air pollution, and improve air quality and biodiversity. As green roofs in the UK increase in use to catch up with Europe, single-ply and bitumen membranes will increase. Single-ply and modified bitumen membranes are engineered to accommodate green roof installations, with features such as root barriers, water retention layers, and enhanced drainage systems.
Solar roofing systems: As renewable energy technologies become more affordable and accessible, integrated solar roofing systems are used to reduce carbon footprint and energy costs. Advances in photovoltaic (PV) technology have led to the development of solar roofing products that seamlessly integrate with single-ply and modified bitumen membranes, generating electricity.
Final thoughts
The choice between single-ply and modified bitumen membranes depends on the project’s specific requirements, the building itself, and your budget. Single-ply membranes offer ease of installation, are lightweight, and are energy efficient. They are also the more affordable roof membrane option. They suit buildings with weight limitations or those seeking to reduce cooling costs. Modified bitumen membranes are preferred for their durability and resistance to traffic, although this comes with increased costs and longer installation times.
As the roofing industry advances, ongoing innovations aim to enhance both membrane types’ performance, sustainability, and integration into evolving building technologies.
POSTED BY 
